Rare Voting System Flips House Seat

Image credit: slate.com

A Democrat who trailed a Republican incumbent in a costly U.S. House race came from behind to emerge as the victor Thursday following extra rounds of tabulations under Maine’s new voting system that’s facing a legal challenge.

Election officials declared Jared Golden the winner, flipping the seat held by two-term Rep. Bruce Poliquin, after a federal judge declined to halt tabulations in the state’s ranked-choice voting system used in last week’s election. It was the first time an incumbent has lost that seat in more than 100 years.

The outcome was a dramatic reversal in the nation’s only test of the ranked-choice voting system used for the first time in U.S. House and Senate races. Golden’s election further strengthens a majority for Democrats who swept into power in the House. His election leaves Sen. Susan Collins, of Maine, the lone Republican member of Congress in New England.

Golden, a Marine Corps veteran, declared himself the “majority consensus winner” and told reporters he wants to bring to Washington, D.C., the type of leadership he saw in the Marines.

“The best leaders were the ones who didn’t worry about who got credit for getting the job done,” he said. “Imagine what Congress could do if we had more leaders like that in Washington?” he added.

The ranked-choice system, approved in 2016, lets voters rank all candidates from first to last on the ballot. If no one gets a majority, then last-place candidates are eliminated and their second-place votes are reallocated.

In this case, Poliquin and Golden both collected 46 percent of first-place votes, with Poliquin maintaining a slim edge of about 2,000 votes. But additional tabulations were triggered because no one collected a majority.

On Thursday, Golden overtook Poliquin after state election officials eliminated two independent candidates who trailed, collectively gathering about 8 percent of first-place votes. A computer algorithm reallocated the second-place votes, giving Golden a lead of nearly 3,000 votes.

Poliquin questioned the election results Thursday under Maine’s ranked-choice voting law. He repeated his claim he “won the constitutional ‘one-person, one-vote’ first-choice election” on Election Day.

Poliquin also said he isn’t abandoning a federal lawsuit in which he seeks to have Maine’s new ranked-choice voting system declared unconstitutional.

The legal challenge by Poliquin and three GOP activists served as the backdrop for the dramatic finale of a hard-fought battle that became the most expensive congressional race in state history.

The lawsuit remains alive even though U.S. District Judge Lance Walker declined Poliquin’s request to stop tabulations.

In his decision, however, the judge said it doesn’t appear the Constitution prohibits an election process with more than one round of ballot counting. He also said it’s plausible the Constitution allows states “sufficient leeway to experiment with the election process.”

Golden said he didn’t think the ongoing litigation would prevent him from being seated in January.

During a press conference, Golden said he’s willing to work with Republicans and that his focus will be on getting things done, not in the ongoing investigations of President Donald Trump. He also said he wouldn’t vote for Democratic California Rep. Nancy Pelosi to serve as House speaker.

Mainers approved ranked-choice voting in a statewide referendum after nine of the previous 11 governors were elected without a majority of the vote.

For now, the ranked-choice voting system is used only in federal races and in statewide primary elections in Maine. It cannot be used in the governor’s race or legislative races because of concerns it runs afoul of the state constitution.

Democratic Gov.-elect Janet Mills has said she will try to amend Maine’s constitution so the system can be used in all elections.

You Might Like


  1. That voting system is unconstitutional because it changes the vote from just a vote for a person to a vote for 2 people.

  2. By 2020 this system needs to be fixed. This is not even a little funny! It is actually scary! I live in America and we are supposed to have laws. Then why aren’t the laws followed? The, what used to be called the Democrat Party, but now they are socialists is running our Country now. And they want to bring our Country down. I don’t think the Patriotic Americans will allow it to happen. But if they come after our guns, which they are saying they are going to, then there will be trouble for our Country. I don’t think anyone wants that. I do not. I do however want politicians to be held accountable for their crimes. If a woman loses its sexist and if a black loses it is racist. Maybe they just wasn’t worth a darn. The politicians need to put America first. The citizens need to be first also. No, they want no borders…let anyone in our Country.
    Give everyone free schooling and free health care. I believe God gave us Trump and President Trump is trying to drain the swamp but it isn’t easy. President Trump is a smart man and if anyone can figure out how to fix our voting system then he can. God help our Country because the socialist have the house now. And look at the first Muslim woman that was voted into office she hates the Jewish people and between her and that idiot that everyone calls “The democrat darlin” (LOL) it seems we are on our way to living in hell. If it wasn’t so disgusting so ridiculous it would be Funny. The way this election has been handled it is like a third world election. And it is a shame.

  3. The communist a.k.a. Democrat party knows no bounds in the election fixing, and they have the audacity to charge Trump with Russia collusion when there is not a scintilla of evidence and there is mountains and mountains of evidence of election fixing by the communist a.k.a. Democrat party and it’s minions. I bet George Soros rigged that election machine! Remember America the communist party only gets by with what we allow it! We are an armed populous guaranteed by the founding fathers to protect ourselves from tyrannical government. Regardless of who is in power

  4. Congress needs to enact a law that makes voting CONSISTENT in all 50 States! That way there’s none of this “confusion”. State/Federal picture ID would be a good start!!!!!!!

  5. Each person that votes should BE REQUIRED to present a voter ID and Their S.S.Card. Mail-in’s should not be allowed. There is buses that could pick people up in every district.

Comments are closed.